"Has Israel Lost Europe?" So asked the program of
this year's Herzliya security conference, in the upscale Tel Aviv
suburb of the same name, of one of its panels, co-sponsored by the
Heinrich Böll Foundation. European diplomats, officials from NGOs and
the occasional interested participant spent three hours discussing
Europe-Israel relations, under a Chatham House Rules agreement that no
one would be quoted by name. To be sure, the "peace process" was
mentioned again and again, much of the time because the European Union
had—mistakenly, some panelists said—linked relations to an agreement
between Israelis and Palestinians.
But the most glaring omission were
the Palestinians themselves—something a few of the participants noted
with dismay after the session. From individual rights straight through
to collective national ones, there was virtually no nod—not even to a
vague notion of empathy—for the Palestinians. Why not? Perhaps because
there were no Palestinians on the panel, or seemingly even in the room
at all. (There didn't seem to be any Palestinians at the conference at
all.)
Panelists and participants held varied opinions on whether Israel actually
had lost
Europe—no mention, of course, to whom—but almost all held a dire
prognosis. "Yes," one participant answered flatly at the top of their
comments, adding that relations were getting worse. Another panelist
issued a warning: "For the moment, you have not lost Europe, but you
will if you don't show your stances." He went on that Europe could
reverse the trend by "stop(ping) that drive Israel into isolation."
Those policies--of settlement expansion--were alliteratively seen as
either the subject of too much focus or, by more critical panelists,
through the European lens "as the biggest threat to two states." (The
journalist Joseph Dana pointed out after the panel that last year the
E.U.
upgraded ties with Israel just weeks after issuing a scathing report on settlements.)
But
for all the talk of how the Europeans view settlements, and the
consequences to relations, it was almost as if these are cities, towns
and outposts built upon a land without a people. One self-described
"pro-Israeli" participant said Europeans needed to understand that
global anti-Semitism went beyond the Holocaust, and that this was part
of the narrative of the rise of Israel. But maybe, as that panelist
said, everyone was too focused on the settlements, but not for wanting of more of the Israeli narrative, but more of the Palestinian one.
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/03/12/but-to-whom-did-israel-lose-europe.html
No comments:
Post a Comment